| Nathan Fillion | John Nolan |
| Mekia Cox | Nyla Harper |
| Alyssa Diaz | Angela Lopez |
| Richard T. Jones | Wade Grey |
| Titus Makin Jr. | Jackson West |
| Melissa O'Neil | Lucy Chen |
| Eric Winter | Tim Bradford |
| Samantha Sloyan | Alice Sheldon |
| Enver Gjokaj | Donovan |
| Jasmine Mathews | Rachel Hall |
| Jordan Belfi | Ross 'Corkscrew' Tegan |
| Margo Gignac | Katrin Arnoux |
| Ashley Argota Torres | Bella |
| Niko Pepaj | Miles |
| Seth Archuleta | Kriff |
| Brock Pierce | Evan |
| Roshan Maloney | Shaky |
| Sallieu Sesay | Kit Room Officer |
| Jeffrey Markle | Bartender |
| Heather Olt | Eileen Ransom |
| River Drosche | Cody Ransom |
| Carsyn Rose | Lila Town |
| Panuvat Anthony Nanakornpanom | Osito |
| Miguel-Andres Garcia | Ranger |
| Trevor Morgan | Spyker |
| Steve 'Stevieweevie' Jones | Lawyer |