| Nathan Fillion | John Nolan |
| Alyssa Diaz | Angela Lopez |
| Richard T. Jones | Wade Grey |
| Titus Makin Jr. | Jackson West |
| Mercedes Mason | Zoe Andersen |
| Melissa O'Neil | Lucy Chen |
| Afton Williamson | Talia Bishop |
| Eric Winter | Tim Bradford |
| Julie Ann Emery | Stacy |
| Kai Lennox | Unicorn Father |
| Mircea Monroe | Isabel Bradford |
| John Nania | Pistol |
| Michael Chaturantabut | Shotgun |
| Mary Albee | Female Foxburg Cop |
| Lauro David Chartrand-DelValle | Male Foxburg Cop |
| Anthony Bonaventura | Selby |
| Eugene Shaw | Darius Nguyen |
| Dorian Kingi | Phoenix |
| Kelly Connolly | Hostage |
| Tessa James | Rey |
| Renes Rivera | Carlo |
| Patrick Sabongui | Ghost Head |
| Johnny D'Esposito | Blaze |
| Dominic A. Iannitti | Lucas aka Unicorn Kid |
| Paula Alvear | Indigo |
| J. Francisco Rodriguez | Gardener |
| Teya Patt | Woman |
| Luing Andrews | Joe Anderson |
| Tamiko Brownlee | Half Dressed Woman |
| Michael I. Goode | Midwest Tourist |
| Gerren Hall | Vistor |
| Jan M. Janssen | Uniformed Officer |
| Reid Kawakami | Darius's Goon |
| Mariano 'Big Dawg' Mendoza | Bodybuilder |
| Vitta Quinn | Lady Gaga Lookalike |
| Darrion Scoggins | Mariachi Plaza Pedestrian |
| Jamin Thompson | Officer Walker |