| Peter Krause | Nate Fisher |
| Michael C. Hall | David Fisher |
| Frances Conroy | Ruth Fisher |
| Lauren Ambrose | Claire Fisher |
| Freddy Rodríguez | Federico 'Rico' Diaz |
| Mathew St. Patrick | Keith Charles
(credit only) |
| Jeremy Sisto | Billy Chenowith |
| Rachel Griffiths | Brenda Chenowith |
| Ed Begley Jr. | Hiram Gunderson |
| Ed O'Ross | Nikolai |
| Marina Black | Parker McKenna |
| Steven Pasquale | Kurt |
| Stewart Finlay-McLennan | Connor Thompson |
| Michael Cudlitz | Dennis, Crossroads Leader |
| Gary Hershberger | Matthew Gilardi |
| Justina Machado | Vanessa Diaz |
| Giancarlo Rodriguez | Julio Diaz |
| Lisa K. Wyatt | Pam, Kroehner Mortician |
| Lori Harmon | Kate, Chloe's Friend |
| Pat Destro | Chloe's Friend |
| Jordan Brower | Topher |
| LaPamela Avant | Guard |
| Jules Tearle | Square Dancer |
| Pamela Rickard | Hiker
(uncredited) |
| Robin Riker | Chloe Yorkin
(uncredited) |
| Larry Ward | Square Dance Leader
(uncredited) |