| Michaela Jaé (MJ) Rodriguez | Blanca Rodriguez |
| Billy Porter | Pray Tell |
| Dominique Jackson | Elektra |
| Indya Moore | Angel |
| Hailie Sahar | Lulu |
| Angel Bismark Curiel | Lil Papi |
| Dyllon Burnside | Ricky |
| Jason A. Rodriguez | Lemar |
| Jeremy Pope | Christopher |
| Noma Dumezweni | Tasha Jackson |
| Jeremy McClain | Cubby |
| Patricia Black | Chi Chi |
| Demosthenes Chrysan | Detective |
| Tiffany Denise Hobbs | Detective Patterson |
| Angelica Ross | Candy |
| Nomi Ruiz | April |
| Joe Carroll | Neil |
| Kevin Alexander | Officer Murphy |
| Mike J Mills | Sketchy Man |
| Andrew Kober | John #1 |
| Michael Kaplan | John #2 |
| Jose Guitierez | Judge #1 |
| Michael Angelo Roberson | Judge #2 |
| Alex Cephus | Capri Capricorn |
| Kiely Colon | House of Capricorn Member #1 |
| Quentin Chauncey Barrett | House of Capricorn Member #2 |
| Athena Francis-Wright | House of Capricorn Member #3 |
| Telloyd Richards | House of Capricorn Member #4 |
| Johnny Castro | Ballroom Member |
| Michael DeBarge | Pedestrian |