| Amy Poehler | Leslie Knope |
| Rashida Jones | Ann Perkins |
| Aziz Ansari | Tom Haverford |
| Nick Offerman | Ron Swanson |
| Aubrey Plaza | April Ludgate |
| Chris Pratt | Andy Dwyer |
| Adam Scott | Ben Wyatt |
| Rob Lowe | Chris Traeger |
| Jim O'Heir | Jerry Gergich |
| Retta | Donna Meagle |
| Pamela Reed | Marlene Knope |
| Martin Starr | Kevin |
| Harris Wittels | Harris |
| Kenny Stevenson | Jim Kabernick |
| Eric Isenhower | Orin |
| Tami D'Addio | Kim
(as Tami Nicole D'Addio) |
| Jordi Vilasuso | Enrico |
| Tom Costello | Jeff |
| Kurt Long | Bill
(as Kurt A. Long) |
| Rogelio Douglas Jr. | Cupid |
| Craig Woolson | Alex |
| Clayton Bright | Champagne Drinker
(uncredited) |
| Jonathan Coulton | Wayne
(uncredited) |
| Ryan Andrew Evans | Server
(uncredited) |
| Bradley Fisher | Lil Sebastian mourner
(uncredited) |
| Megan Harwick | Jim Kabernick's Wife
(uncredited) |
| Zoe Sharpe | Shelly
(uncredited) |
| Steven T Stanton | Donna's Guy
(uncredited) |