| Amy Poehler | Leslie Knope |
| Rashida Jones | Ann Perkins |
| Paul Schneider | Mark Brendanawicz |
| Aziz Ansari | Tom Haverford |
| Aubrey Plaza | April Ludgate |
| Chris Pratt | Andy Dwyer |
| Louis C.K. | Dave Sanderson |
| Jim O'Heir | Jerry Gergich |
| Jim Meskimen | Martin Housely |
| Retta | Donna Meagle |
| Susan Yeagley | Jessica Wicks |
| April Eden | Trish Ianetta
(as April Marie Eden) |
| Linda Montana | Denise Yermley |
| Anne Gregory | Susan
(as Anne Elizabeth Gregory) |
| Frank Medrano | Ray |
| Worth Howe | Charles |
| Amy E. | Irish Dance Contestant |
| Fred Ochs | Craig |
| Louisa Dienst | Pageant Contestant
(uncredited) |
| Tania Pilar | Pageant Contestant
(uncredited) |