| Patrick Jordan | Librarian |
| Sonny Valicenti | ADT Serviceman |
| Holt McCallany | Bill Tench |
| Zachary Scott Ross | Brian Tench |
| Stacey Roca | Nancy Tench |
| Jonathan Groff | Holden Ford |
| Albert Jones | Jim Barney |
| David Carranza | Virginia Sheriff's Deputy |
| Nate Corddry | Detective Art Spencer |
| Michael Filipowich | William Pierce Jr. |
| Steven Daniel Brun | Andre |
| Sierra Aylina McClain | Tanya Clifton
(as Sierra McClain) |
| Kevin Tre'von Patterson | Ernest |
| June Carryl | Camille Bell |
| Andrene Ward-Hammond | Venus Taylor |
| Crystal Lee Brown | Willie Mae Mathis |
| Anna Torv | Dr. Wendy Carr |
| Corey Allen | William Henry Hance |
| Brent Sexton | Garland Periwinkle |
| Joe Tuttle | Gregg Smith |
| Don O. Knowlton | Father Monaghan |
| Paul Carafotes | Rod |
| Megan McQuillan | Harriet |
| Drew Seltzer | Dale Harmon |
| Lauren Glazier | Kay Manz |
| Mike Ancas | Airport Traveler
(uncredited) |
| Saira Awan | Churchgoer Wife
(uncredited) |
| Thea Camara | Baltimore Grandmother
(uncredited) |
| Megan Cook | Churchgoer
(uncredited) |
| Giordan Dixon | Prison Inmate
(uncredited) |
| Joe Fishel | Marine
(uncredited) |
| Jake Moon | Traveler
(uncredited) |
| Frankie Palombi | Off-Duty Police Officer
(uncredited) |
| Christian Stavrakis | Black Cap Suspect
(uncredited) |