| Jerry Orbach | Detective Lennie Briscoe |
| Benjamin Bratt | Detective Rey Curtis |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Sam Waterston | E.A.D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Carey Lowell | A.D.A. Jamie Ross |
| Steven Hill | D.A. Adam Schiff |
| Donna Murphy | Carla Tyrell |
| James Handy | Mr. Wheeler |
| Sig Libowitz | Defense Attorney Stan Shatenstein |
| Charles Levin | Mr. Shuster |
| Susan Blommaert | Trial Judge Rebecca Steinman |
| Suzanne Costollos | Mrs. Wheeler |
| Ellen Muth | Adele Green |
| Michael C. Maronna | Tagger |
| Rob McElhenney | Joey Timon |
| Reed Birney | Attorney for Archdiocese |
| Jan Munroe | Father Galva |
| John Tormey | Tommy DeLuca |
| Bill Christ | Rev. Gervais |
| John Fiore | Detective Tony Profaci |
| Thomas McHugh | Det. Byrne |
| Nick Wyman | Judge Gavin Mickerson |
| Ava-Marie Carnevale | Mrs. Timon |
| Anne Lange | Headmistress |
| Cynthia Hayden | Mrs. Green |
| David S. Howard | Mr. Morris |
| Jim Doerr | Sheehan |
| Bob Ari | Owner |
| Pat Moya | Deborah Curtis |
| Rosanna Carter | Mrs. Hemmerick |
| Herb Lovelle | Mr. Hemmerick |
| Kevin Hurley | Brother |
| Christopher Innvar | Elliot Gill |
| Joe Zaloom | Avi |
| William Pitts | Phone Company Worker |
| Melissa Marsala | Marlene |
| Bryan Greenberg | Matt Wheeler |
| Deirdre Lovejoy | CSU Technician |
| David Edward Jones | Police Officer |
| Al Cayne | Hispanic Kid |
| Beau Berdahl Oliver | Student |
| Brooke Stone | Jaclyn |
| Steven Zirnkilton | Narrator |