| Jeremy Sisto | Detective Cyrus Lupo |
| Anthony Anderson | Detective Kevin Bernard |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Linus Roache | E.A.D.A. Michael Cutter |
| Alana De La Garza | A.D.A. Connie Rubirosa |
| Sam Waterston | D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Angela Goethals | Maura Scott |
| Paul Schulze | Mr. Kralik |
| John Speredakos | A.U.S.A. Schlicter |
| Leslie Hendrix | Dr. Elizabeth Rodgers |
| Deirdre O'Connell | Dr. Valerie Knight |
| J.K. Simmons | Dr. Emil Skoda |
| Ernie Hudson | Frank Gibson |
| Lindsey Vonn | Secretary |
| James Biberi | Chief of Detectives Laird |
| Ash Christian | John Nolte |
| Joe Forbrich | Detective Joe Cormack |
| Andrew Pastides | Rick Benson |
| Ed Jewett | Bendel |
| Chris Ceraso | Fontova |
| Gustave Johnson | Hanlon |
| Ted Koch | Paul |
| Amy Tribbey | Rachel |
| Robert Jimenez | Mr. Cortina |
| Stephen Beach | Prelutsky |
| Wally Dunn | Ron Kozlowski |
| Marissa Matrone | Lott |
| Jeremy Beck | Detective Jena |
| Gabriel Millman | Crowder |
| James Nuciforo | Captain Lagle |
| Tony Campisi | Grand Jury Foreman |
| Bill Cwikowski | Mr. Benson |
| Becky London | Mrs. Benson |
| Jason Fisher | Rob |
| Taylor John Borodavka | Vinnie |
| Nadia Alexander | Morgan |
| Conor Leslie | Eliza |
| Edelen McWilliams | Morgan's Mom |
| Malachi Weir | MRI Technician |
| Sheila Stasack | Grand Juror #2 |
| J.J. Kandel | Grand Juror #3 |
| Kimberly Hebert Gregory | Grand Juror #4 |
| Sidney Williams | Muir |
| Patrick Murney | Dwayne Phillips |
| Malachy Cleary | Sergeant Gutfeld |
| Aaron Schwartz | Bomb Squad Cop |
| Eric L. Abrams | Trooper Alfonzo |
| Lena Kaminsky | Teacher in Library |
| Anthony C. Mazza | ESU Sergeant |
| Ayana Brown | First Cop |
| Jonathan Gutierrez | Manuel |
| Deema Aitken | Student |
| Victoria Beltran | Trophy Wife |
| Nick Dillenburg | ESU Cop |
| Alisha Gaddis | Legal Assistant |
| Ed Kalegi | Suspended Teacher |
| Mark Parra | Detective |
| Anastasia Mousis Sanidopoulos | Teacher |
| Edwin Guerrero | Lawyer |
| Gina Rados | Grand Juror |
| Steven Weisz | NYPD Captain |