| Jeremy Sisto | Detective Cyrus Lupo |
| Anthony Anderson | Detective Kevin Bernard |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Linus Roache | E.A.D.A. Michael Cutter |
| Alana De La Garza | A.D.A. Connie Rubirosa |
| Sam Waterston | D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Anna Gunn | Marielle Di Napoli |
| Reg Rogers | Joshua Felner |
| Michael Bunin | Marty Ashcroft |
| Joanna Adler | Barbara Speight |
| Katy Selverstone | Marielle's Attorney |
| Leslie Hendrix | M.E. Dr. Elizabeth Rodgers |
| Ernie Hudson | Frank Gibson |
| Alysia Reiner | Amy Felner |
| Angela Christian | Suzanne Ashcroft |
| Orlagh Cassidy | Detective Sheila Ray |
| Matt Landers | Judge Mark Lee |
| Michael Cullen | Judge Connor Yorith |
| Joel Leffert | Jerry |
| Oliver Vaquer | Jack Nunez |
| Lee Dolson | Jason |
| Anna Stone | Ellen Taylor |
| Tom Titone | Frank Stavro |
| Lisa Birnbaum | Carol |
| Dan Domingues | Karl |
| Danny Deferrari | Nick |
| Sonnie Brown | Assistant Medical Examiner |
| Cindy Keiter | Jury Forewoman |
| Lou Irizarry | Clerk |
| Bradley Dean Jones | Court Clerk |
| Dj Nino Carta | Perp |
| Kelly Karavites | Newspaper Reporter |
| Anne Lockhart | Policewoman |
| James Schram | Inconvenienced Resident |