| Dennis Farina | Detective Joe Fontana |
| Jesse L. Martin | Detective Ed Green |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Sam Waterston | E.A.D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Annie Parisse | A.D.A. Alexandra Borgia |
| Fred Thompson | D.A. Arthur Branch |
| Allan Miller | Rabbi Geller |
| Zach Grenier | Barry Speicher |
| Kevin O'Rourke | Stan Malloy |
| Leslie Hendrix | M.E. Dr. Elizabeth Rodgers |
| Gerry Bamman | Arraignment Judge Thomas Everton |
| Mark Feuerstein | Eric Speicher |
| John Cariani | CSU Technician Julian Beck |
| Selenis Leyva | Detective Mariluz Rivera |
| Tina Benko | Sharon Quaid |
| Tibor Feldman | Ken Rosenberg |
| Libby George | Judge Iris Chapman |
| Lisa Gorlitsky | Rachel Speicher |
| Bridget Barkan | Kayla Watson |
| Arian Moayed | Fadi Abu Ubdeh |
| Fred Berman | Orthodox #1 |
| Buzz Bovshow | Orthodox #2 |
| Zachary Knower | Chayim |
| Kevin Prowse | Santiago |
| Viola Harris | Elderly Woman |
| Sean McCourt | Assistant M.E. |
| Laura Kai Chen | Amanda Yuen |
| Ebrahim Jaffer | Imam Adiani |
| Bob Stillman | Father Royce |
| Randy Schein | Man |
| Leslie Shenkel | First Jewish Man |
| Erik Solky | Second Jewish Man |
| Harry Madsen | Third Jewish Man |
| Shiya Ribowsky | Cantor |
| Alex Dawson | Paralegal |
| Ken Krugman | Foreperson |
| Paul Borghese | Clerk |
| Cristina Duarte | Officer |
| Gallery Guest | Gallery Guest |
| Tanda Kerín | Gallery Guest |
| Wendy Alane Wright | Julia Bennett |
| Charles Coxe | Jeffrey Kilgore |
| Alissa Laderer | Waitress |
| Sonny Vellozzi | Gallery Member |
| Steven Zirnkilton | Narrator |