| Dennis Farina | Detective Joe Fontana |
| Jesse L. Martin | Detective Ed Green |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Sam Waterston | E.A.D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Elisabeth Röhm | A.D.A. Serena Southerlyn |
| Fred Thompson | D.A. Arthur Branch |
| Chris Sarandon | Howard Pincham |
| Robin Thomas | Connecticut Governor Michael Riordan |
| Jeremy Webb | Devin Bradley |
| Kelly Deadmon | Nicole Temple |
| Leslie Hendrix | M.E. Dr. Elizabeth Rodgers |
| Stephen Singer | Larry Levine |
| David Leary | Justice R. Truffin |
| Zeljko Ivanek | Richard Kaplan |
| Mark Zimmerman | Trial Judge Nathan Murphy |
| Fran Lebowitz | Judge Janice Goldberg |
| Selenis Leyva | Detective Mariluz Rivera |
| Todd Weeks | New Paltz Mayor Jonas Carpentino |
| Nancy Giles | Claudia Gaines |
| James Caulfield | Judge Gerald Slojakovitch |
| Peter Macon | Troy Hill |
| Christy Baron | Deidre Livingston |
| John Carter | Appellate Court Justice |
| Eric McLendon | Robert DuBois |
| Kate Nowlin | Alison |
| Michael Mazzeo | Court Clerk |
| John Forest | Mark |
| Ken Goodstein | Band Leader |
| Brenda Ricci | Maggie Riordan |
| Susan McBrien | Shocked Juror |
| Sonny Vellozzi | Cocktail Party Guest |
| Steven Zirnkilton | Narrator |