| Timothy Olyphant | Raylan Givens |
| Nick Searcy | Art Mullen
(credit only) |
| Jere Burns | Wynn Duffy
(credit only) |
| Joelle Carter | Ava Crowder |
| Jacob Pitts | Tim Gutterson
(credit only) |
| Erica Tazel | Rachel Brooks
(credit only) |
| Walton Goggins | Boyd Crowder |
| Michael Rapaport | Daryl Crowe Jr. |
| Kyle Bornheimer | Jack |
| A.J. Buckley | Danny Crowe |
| Dale Dickey | Judith |
| William Forsythe | Michael |
| Damon Herriman | Dewey Crowe |
| Jesse Luken | Jimmy Tolan |
| Jacob Lofland | Kendal Crowe |
| Danielle Panabaker | Penny |
| Amy Smart | Allison |
| Alicia Witt | Wendy Crowe |
| Deidrie Henry | Rowena |
| J. Anthony Pena | Corey Flores |
| Justin Welborn | Carl |
| Jocelyn Ayanna | Officer Barbour |
| Monty Cox | Retiree |
| Justin Huen | Alberto Ruiz |
| Anthony Ledesma | Henchman #1 |
| Jorge Lopez | Mateo |
| Rolando Molina | Aguilar |
| Vincent Rivera | Silvano |
| David Meunier | Johnny Crowder
(uncredited) |
| Lisa Pevc | Aryan Inmate
(uncredited) |
| Jason Tobias | Drug Thug
(uncredited) |