| Kyle Chandler | Eric Taylor |
| Connie Britton | Tami Taylor |
| Gaius Charles | Brian 'Smash' Williams |
| Zach Gilford | Matt Saracen |
| Minka Kelly | Lyla Garrity |
| Taylor Kitsch | Tim Riggins |
| Adrianne Palicki | Tyra Collette |
| Jesse Plemons | Landry Clarke |
| Scott Porter | Jason Street |
| Aimee Teegarden | Julie Taylor |
| Peter Berg | Morris 'Mo' McArnold |
| Glenn Morshower | Chad Clarke |
| Kevin Rankin | Herc |
| Brad Leland | Buddy Garrity |
| Matt Czuchry | Chris Kennedy |
| Ben Ciaramello | Santiago Herrera
(as Benny Ciaramello) |
| Jana Kramer | Noelle Davenport |
| Derek Phillips | Billy Riggins |
| Liz Mikel | Corrina Williams |
| Whitney McCauley | Sheila Williams |
| Nieko Mann | Noannie Williams |
| Louanne Stephens | Grandma Saracen |
| Blue Deckert | Coach Mac McGill |
| Tamara Jolaine | Erin
(as Tamara Haasan) |
| Brea Grant | Jean Binnel |
| Carol Farabee | Mary Clarke |
| Sid Johnson | Reverend Grady
(as Pastor Sid Johnson) |
| Mathew Greer | Coach Deeks |
| Kenneth Wayne Bradley | Alabama Recruiter |
| Quenby Bakke | Mrs. Kennedy |
| David Morrison | Dad Kennedy |
| Sylvia Luedtke | Grandmother Kennedy |
| Shauna McLean | Helena Kennedy |
| Katie Fountain | Katie Kennedy |
| Kelley Johnson | Kellie Kennedy |
| Joe Grisaffi | Engineer |
| Doug Jackson | Hospital CEO |
| Davi Jay | Marcus Spires |
| Wanda Phillips | Mrs. McGowan |
| Jeffrey Schmidt | Reeves Castle |
| Justin Meeks | Waiter
(as Justin Malloy) |
| David Kanne | Tim Dooley |
| Odell Grant | Parishioner #1 |
| David Cowgill | Slammin' Sammy |
| Gene Cervenka | Churchgoer
(uncredited) |
| Archie Fields | Panther Football Player
(uncredited) |
| Gary Jerome | Press Reg
(uncredited) |
| Scott Mueller | Football Player
(uncredited) |
| Joshua Ryan | Greer - Football Player #12
(uncredited) |
| Nadia Sahari | Nadia
(uncredited) |
| Dother Sykes | Marcus Spires
(uncredited) |
| Gary Teague | Teacher
(uncredited) |
| Debbi Tucker | Churchgoer /
shopper
(uncredited) |
| Heath Young | Football fan
(uncredited) |