| Sarah Michelle Gellar | Buffy Summers |
| Nicholas Brendon | Xander Harris |
| Alyson Hannigan | Willow Rosenberg |
| Charisma Carpenter | Cordelia Chase |
| David Boreanaz | Angel |
| Seth Green | Oz |
| Anthony Head | Rupert Giles
(as Anthony Stewart Head) |
| Kristine Sutherland | Joyce Summers |
| Alexis Denisof | Wesley Wyndam-Pryce |
| Ethan Erickson | Percy West |
| Danny Strong | Jonathan Levinson |
| Larry Bagby | Larry Blaisdell
(as Larry Bagby III) |
| Keram Malicki-Sánchez | Freddy Iverson
(as Keram Malicki-Sanchez) |
| Justin Doran | Hogan Martin |
| Lauren E. Roman | Nancy Doyle
(as Lauren Roman) |
| Wendy Worthington | Lunch Lady |
| Robert Arce | Mr. Beach |
| Molly Bryant | Ms. Murray |
| Rich Muller | Student |
| Jay Michael Ferguson | Another Student |
| Adena Bjork | Student
(uncredited) |
| Michael Manasseri | Horned Demon
(archive footage) (uncredited) |