| Rachel Brosnahan | Miriam 'Midge' Maisel |
| Alex Borstein | Susie Myerson |
| Michael Zegen | Joel Maisel |
| Marin Hinkle | Rose Weissman |
| Caroline Aaron | Shirley Maisel |
| Tony Shalhoub | Abe Weissman |
| Jane Lynch | Sophie Lennon |
| John Waters | Lazarus |
| Reid Scott | Gordon Ford |
| Jason Alexander | Asher Friedman |
| Max Casella | Michael Kessler |
| Joel Johnstone | Archie Cleary |
| Stephanie Hsu | Mei |
| John Scurti | Nicky |
| Erik Palladino | Frank |
| Gideon Glick | Alfie |
| Santino Fontana | Boise |
| Kayli Carter | Gloria |
| Matilda Szydagis | Zelda |
| James Monroe Iglehart | Charlie |
| Joe Carroll | Liam |
| Allison Guinn | Bunny |
| Raven Bowens | Tilly |
| Kirsten Wyatt | Mitzi |
| Darien Crago | Sugar |
| Lilin Lace | Lana |
| Matthew Jeffers | Russell |
| Jordan Sobel | Waiter |
| Ric Stoneback | Alfred Hitchcock |
| Alise Morales | Isobel |
| Tally Sessions | Smartly-Dressed Man |
| Brady Adair | Another Man |
| Sarah Elizabeth Hewitt | Secretary |
| Cait Cortelyou | Woman |
| Brian Calì | Bartender |
| Nancy Cantine | Trixie |
| Quinn VanAntwerp | Agent Webber |
| Jillian Schmitz | Wolford Dancer - Philomena |
| Rosie Cheeks | Wolford Dancer - Sapphira |
| Ivory Fox | Wolford Dancer - Bubbles |
| Alexi Irvine | Wolford Dancer - Gilded Age |
| Joli W. Irvine | Wolford Dancer - CanCan Mademoiselle |
| Ariel Ash | Wolford Dancer - Cotton Ball |
| Aubree Brown | Wolford Dancer - Annie Oakley |
| Dayne Board | Wolford Dancer - Ringmaster |
| Jourdan Epstein | Button Club Waitress |
| Deanna B. Tomasetta | Button Club Waitress |
| Sarah Beymer | Button Club Dancer |
| Amanda LaMotte | Button Club Dancer |
| Christopher Jarosz | Button Club Dancer |
| Alex Wong | Button Club Dancer |
| Loriel Hennington | Trapped Door Dancer |
| Marcy Richardson | Trapped Door Dancer |
| Elyse Niederee | Trapped Door Dancer |
| Jenna Stocks | Trapped Door Dancer |
| Angeliq Brock | Greenwich Village Dancer |
| Rachel Hospers | Greenwich Village Dancer |
| J.D. Aubrey Smith | Greenwich Village Dancer |
| Steven Alan Black | Village Voice Staff |
| Frank Bonsangue | Driver |
| Pearls Daily | Burlesque dancer |
| Sam Sherwood | Button Club Bandleader |
| Iván Amaro Bullón | Wolford Patron |
| David Carraturo | Wolford Patron |
| Jason DeStefano | Bouncer at Wolford |
| Jason Hewitt | Wolford Patron |
| Daniel Hirsh | Wolford Patron |