| Jared Padalecki | Sam Winchester |
| Jensen Ackles | Dean Winchester |
| Hank Harris | Gerry /
Boltar the Furious |
| Tiffany Dupont | Gilda |
| Don Thompson | Sheriff Jake Miller |
| Felicia Day | Charlie Bradbury |
| Haig Sutherland | Lance Jacobsen |
| Shaughnessy Redden | Ed Nelson |
| Richard Meen | Charlie's sparring partner |
| Larissa Dias | Lady Elf
(as Larissa Albuquerque) |
| Andrea Brooks | Maria /
Gholandria the Wicked |
| Robert Sidley | Shadow Orc in Stocks |
| Michael Teigen | Max Hilby /
Shadow King |
| Theo Wiersma | Shadow Orc |
| Attila | Elf
(uncredited) |
| Liane Balaban | Amelia Richardson
(archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Eoin Bates | Elfin Warrior
(uncredited) |
| Ty Olsson | Benny Lafitte
(archive footage) (uncredited) |