| Giovanni Ribisi | Pete Murphy |
| Marin Ireland | Julia Bowman |
| Shane McRae | Taylor Bowman |
| Libe Barer | Carly Bowman |
| Peter Gerety | Otto Bernhardt |
| Margo Martindale | Audrey Bernhardt |
| Jane Adams | Maggie |
| Ethan Embry | Pete Murphy |
| Jay O. Sanders | Sam |
| Joseph Lyle Taylor | Frank |
| Jennifer Ferrin | Joyce Roby |
| Desmond Harrington | Joe |
| Michael Oberholtzer | Colin |
| Lois Smith | Reverend Ethel Landry |
| Heather Burns | Trish |
| Jacob Pitts | Lance Lord |
| Thomas Kopache | Arlo |
| Yvonna Kopacz Wright | Delores |
| Samrat Chakrabarti | Raj |
| Mark Zimmerman | Ariel Botvinik |
| Charlotte Ray Rosenberg | Laney |
| Katy Grenfell | Liz |
| Suzanne Froix | Doreen |
| Tyrone Mitchell Henderson | Evan |
| Terry Greiss | Terry |
| Alexander Khait | Armed Hasidic Guard 1 |
| Billy Eric | Homeless Guy |
| Ken Wulf Clark | Mechanic |
| George Aloi | Psychic Board Member |
| Brett Berg | Rabbi |
| Vava Buitenkant | Psychic Board Member |
| Michele Rave Grassani | Hasidic Man |
| James Andrew O'Connor | Merle |