| Jason Bateman | Martin 'Marty' Byrde |
| Laura Linney | Wendy Byrde |
| Sofia Hublitz | Charlotte Byrde |
| Skylar Gaertner | Jonah Byrde |
| Julia Garner | Ruth Langmore |
| Charlie Tahan | Wyatt Langmore |
| Lisa Emery | Darlene Snell |
| Janet McTeer | Helen Pierce |
| Tom Pelphrey | Ben Davis |
| Jessica Frances Dukes | Special Agent Maya Miller |
| McKinley Belcher III | Agent Trevor Evans |
| Darren Goldstein | Charles Wilkes |
| John Bedford Lloyd | Frank Cosgrove |
| Joseph Sikora | Frank Cosgrove Jr. |
| Felix Solis | Omar Navarro |
| Damian Young | Jim Rattelsdorf |
| Kevin L. Johnson | Sam Dermody |
| Melissa Saint-Amand | Jade |
| Adrienne Ballenger | Godparent #2 |
| Nelson Bonilla | Nelson |
| Allyssa Brooke | Mother |
| Mike Endoso | Godparent #1 |
| Juan Hernandez | Priest |
| Stephan Jones | Guard |
| Lucas Meinhart | Young Boy |
| Tessa Anderson | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Gissette Valentin | Navarro Girlfriend |
| Jenin Gonzalez | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Donovan Williams | Craps Dealer |
| Thomas Maldonado | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Jane Oshita | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Charles Picerni | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Juan Jose Reyes | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Blanca Rosa Rosario | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Ayami Sakaeda | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Jesus Trujillo | Baptism Attendees - Congregants |
| Marc Canonizado | Baptism Attendees - Navarro's Men |
| John Cihangir | Baptism Attendees - Navarro's Men |
| Veasna Keo | Baptism Attendees - Navarro's Men |
| Christopher Klorca | Baptism Attendees - Navarro's Men |
| Fernando Campos | Baptism Attendees - Gun Men |
| Justin Ortiz | Baptism Attendees - Gun Men |
| Kenny Waymack Jr. | Baptism Attendees - Gun Men |
| James J. Zito III | Triggerman |
| Christopher Cocke | Casino Gambler |
| Andrew R. Kaplan | Craps Dealer |
| Eeryn Falk Lubicich | Market Patron |
| Wendy Prescott Luke | Casino Patron |
| Kerstyn Murray | Gambler |
| Victoria Paige Watkins | Neighbor |