| Tom Ellis | Lucifer Morningstar |
| Lauren German | Chloe Decker |
| Kevin Alejandro | Dan Espinoza |
| D.B. Woodside | Amenadiel
(as DB Woodside) |
| Lesley-Ann Brandt | Mazikeen |
| Aimee Garcia | Ella Lopez |
| Brianna Hildebrand | Rory
(credit only) |
| Rachael Harris | Linda Martin |
| Inbar Lavi | Eve |
| Scott Porter | Carol Corbett |
| Matt Corboy | Officer Diggs |
| Bjorn Johnson | Magnar |
| Elizabeth Grullon | Erika
(as Elizabeth Grullón) |
| Chris Coy | Alan |
| Deyo Forteza | Keaton Call |
| Eddie Blackwell Williams | Belios
(as Eddie Blackwell) |
| Maggie Carney | Theater Manager |
| Adam Wylie | Short Magician |
| Rob Zabrecky | Horace Goldfinger |
| Ernesto Chaverri | Responding Officer
(uncredited) |