| Tom Ellis | Lucifer Morningstar |
| Lauren German | Chloe Decker |
| Kevin Alejandro | Dan Espinoza |
| Tricia Helfer | Charlotte |
| D.B. Woodside | Amenadiel
(as DB Woodside) (credit only) |
| Lesley-Ann Brandt | Mazikeen |
| Aimee Garcia | Ella Lopez |
| Scarlett Estevez | Trixie Espinoza |
| Tom Welling | Marcus Pierce |
| Rachael Harris | Linda Martin
(credit only) |
| Kevin Carroll | Sinnerman |
| Britt Baron | Maggie Cole |
| Anastasia Leddick | Helena Handbasket |
| Taylor C. Baker | Bedazzled Skater
(as Taylor C Baker) |
| Anissa Borrego | Barista |
| Nicole Dele | Vanessa |
| Diana Cristina Solis | Blindfolded Hottie
(as Diana Solis) |