| Jesse L. Martin | Detective Ed Green |
| Milena Govich | Detective Nina Cassady |
| S. Epatha Merkerson | Lieutenant Anita Van Buren |
| Sam Waterston | E.A.D.A. Jack McCoy |
| Alana De La Garza | A.D.A. Connie Rubirosa |
| Fred Thompson | D.A. Arthur Branch |
| Jaymie Dornan | John Carroll |
| Todd Gearhart | Attorney Rosenthal |
| José Zúñiga | Detective Borough Investigator |
| Terri Garber | Mrs. Carroll |
| Paul Anthony Stewart | Bobby Gold |
| Jack Koenig | Carroll's Attorney |
| Ami Brabson | Judge Cale |
| Jennifer Esposito | Justine Bailey |
| Chevy Chase | Mitch Carroll |
| Leia Thompson | Tori |
| John Cariani | CSU Technician Julian Beck |
| Mark Zimmerman | Trial Judge Nathan Murphy |
| Mark Kenneth Smaltz | Judge William Koehler |
| Kevin Stapleton | Don Hamilton |
| Patrick Boll | Barry Bishop |
| Nicoye Banks | Officer Taylor |
| Zack Robidas | Officer Simone |
| Teddy Cañez | Det. Davis |
| Austin Jones | CSU Tech |
| Susanna Guzman | Nurse Esposito |
| Joseph Edward | Court Clerk |
| Charlie Sandlan | Detective Marlo |
| Matthew DeCapua | Uniform |
| Lena Armstrong | Jury Foreperson |
| Marisa Kinsey | Member of MSNBC Press |
| Bill Walters | Courtroom Spectator |
| Steven Zirnkilton | Narrator |