| Timothy Olyphant | Raylan Givens |
| Nick Searcy | Art Mullen |
| Jere Burns | Wynn Duffy |
| Joelle Carter | Ava Crowder |
| Jacob Pitts | Tim Gutterson |
| Erica Tazel | Rachel Brooks |
| Walton Goggins | Boyd Crowder |
| Michael Rapaport | Daryl Crowe Jr. |
| Edi Gathegi | Jean Baptiste |
| David Meunier | Johnny Crowder |
| Sam Anderson | Lee Paxton |
| Adam Arkin | Theo Tonin |
| A.J. Buckley | Danny Crowe |
| Rick Gomez | AUSA David Vasquez |
| Steve Harris | Roscoe |
| Wood Harris | Jay |
| Damon Herriman | Dewey Crowe |
| John Kapelos | Picker |
| Jesse Luken | Jimmy Tolan |
| Jacob Lofland | Kendal Crowe |
| Danny Strong | Albert Fekus |
| Alan Tudyk | Elias Marcos
(as Wray Nerely) |
| Don McManus | The Wildman |
| Will Sasso | Al Sura |
| Amy Smart | Allison |
| Mickey Jones | Rodney 'Hot Rod' Dunham |
| Alicia Witt | Wendy Crowe |
| William Gregory Lee | Nick Mooney |
| Karolina Wydra | Mara Paxton |
| Branton Box | Gunnar Swift |
| Christopher Carrington | Bobby Forrester |
| Mel Fair | Deputy U.S. Marshal Nelson Dunlop |
| Kaitlin Ferrell | Teena |
| Patrick Hume | Hayes Workman |
| Jim Klock | Desk Officer |
| Jonathan Kowalsky | Mike |
| Laura Niemi | Sally |
| Tom Riordan | SWAT Officer
(as Thomas Riordan) |
| Frankie Sims | Waitress |
| Reggie Watkins | Ali |
| Aubrey Wood | Mina |
| Lisa Pevc | Aryan Inmate
(uncredited) |