| Joel McHale | Jeff Winger |
| Gillian Jacobs | Britta Perry |
| Danny Pudi | Abed Nadir |
| Yvette Nicole Brown | Shirley Bennett |
| Alison Brie | Annie Edison |
| Donald Glover | Troy Barnes |
| Jim Rash | Dean Pelton |
| Ken Jeong | Ben Chang |
| Chevy Chase | Pierce Hawthorne |
| French Stewart | Vinnie |
| J.P. Manoux | Faux-by |
| Jim Meskimen | Christopher Walken Impersonator |
| Blake Anderson | Attendant |
| Richard Erdman | Leonard |
| Brandon Killham | Howie |
| Bruce Carter | Morgan Freeman Impersonator |
| Pavel Sfera | Bono Impersonator |
| Shawn Pelofsky | Jewish Lady 1 |
| Iris Braydon | Jewish Lady 2 |
| Michelle Azar | Jewish Lady 3 |
| David Born | Robin Williams Impersonator |
| Max Barakat | Ted |
| Susan Grace | Old Jewish Grandmother |
| Shak Ghacha | 18 Year Old |
| Brett Gilbert | Howie's Dad |
| Holly Beavon | Madonna Lookalike |
| Sancho Martin | Lorenzo Lamas Impersonator |
| Rachel Paquin | Geena Davis Impersonator |