| Kathryn Morris | Lilly Rush |
| Danny Pino | Scotty Valens |
| John Finn | John Stillman |
| Jeremy Ratchford | Nick Vera |
| Thom Barry | Will Jeffries |
| Tracie Thoms | Kat Miller |
| Tess Harper | Sharon Lertola '09 |
| Madeline Carroll | Hillary Rhodes '63 |
| Kay Lenz | Hillary Rhodes '09 |
| Valerie Azlynn | Sharon Lertola '63 |
| Bill Bolender | Mike 'Monkey' Mack '09 |
| John Bennett Perry | Al 'Baltimore Red' Soddenheim '09 |
| Channon Roe | John 'The Doctor' Norwood '63 |
| Muse Watson | John Norwood '09 |
| P.J. Marino | Tom Puckett |
| Lucas Caleb Rooney | The Duke '63 |
| Eion Bailey | Patrick 'The Rifle' Lennox '63 |
| Raymond J. Barry | Paul Cooper |
| Brian Elerding | Mike 'Monkey' Mack '63 |
| Nick Hoffa | Opponent '63 |
| Billy Jayne | Al 'Baltimore Red' Soddenheim '63 |
| Kevin Makely | Ben Scavo '63 |
| Michael McKiddy | Bartender '63 |
| Lora Witty | Woman '63 |
| Jeffrey Mowery | Lenny the Hoagie Vendor |
| John Kennedy Jr. | Self |