| Kathryn Morris | Lilly Rush |
| Danny Pino | Scotty Valens |
| John Finn | John Stillman |
| Jeremy Ratchford | Nick Vera |
| Thom Barry | Will Jeffries |
| Hunter Allan | Troy Cage - 1945 |
| Ed Bernard | Moody Brown |
| Beau Billingslea | Willie Dandridge - 2005 |
| Sarah Joy Brown | Josie Sutton |
| Ron Dean | Troy Cage - 2005 |
| Elinor Donahue | Esther 'Legs' Davis - 2005 |
| Arlen Escarpeta | Clyde Taylor |
| Frank Faucette | Willie Dandridge - 1945 |
| Mitchell Fink | Tyler Cage |
| Christina Hendricks | Esther 'Legs' Davis - 1945 |
| Thomas Kopache | Crumbs - 2005 |
| Eric Ladin | Crumbs - 1945 |
| Alveraz Ricardez | Catcher |
| David Ruprecht | Radio Broadcaster |
| Dennis Singletary | Satchel Paige |
| Antonio Lewis Todd | Jackie Robinson |
| Don Wallace | Leon 'Moody' Brown - 1945 |
| Kameron Winston-Lucas | Leonard Hughes |
| Hawk Younkins | Dan Saller |