| Sarah Michelle Gellar | Buffy Summers |
| Nicholas Brendon | Xander Harris |
| Emma Caulfield Ford | Anya
(as Emma Caulfield) |
| Michelle Trachtenberg | Dawn Summers |
| James Marsters | Spike |
| Alyson Hannigan | Willow Rosenberg |
| Anthony Head | Rupert Giles
(as Anthony Stewart Head) |
| Eliza Dushku | Faith |
| Nathan Fillion | Caleb |
| Tom Lenk | Andrew Wells |
| Iyari Limon | Kennedy |
| Sarah Hagan | Amanda |
| Harry Groener | Mayor Richard Wilkins |
| D.B. Woodside | Principal Robin Wood
(as DB Woodside) |
| Felicia Day | Vi |
| Dania Ramirez | Caridad |
| Lisa Ann Cabasa | Injured Girl |
| Lance E. Nichols | Middle-Aged Man |
| Alex Baik | Demon
(uncredited) |
| Denise Emery | Slayerette
(uncredited) |
| Bruno Gunn | Captured Bringer
(uncredited) |
| Kristy Wu | Chao-Ahn
(uncredited) |